Simon predicted that Amy Davis would be in trouble following her “incredibly cabaret” rendition of Connie Francis’ “Where the Boys Are”—and he was right. The 25-year-old trade show model, lacking the Patsy Cline twang that could have made her Idol debut something to remember, according to the judges, was the first girl sent packing despite Paula Abdul’s acknowledgment that the camera just loved the leggy brunette. Asia’h Epperson had no problem with the first round of cuts as both the judges and voters have warmed up to her and her tragic loss of her father.